Which car were Sam and Dean from ‘Supernatural’ supposed to have instead of the 67′ Chevy Impala?By David MillerIn TV Shows TriviaW View AnswerA 1965 Mustang.Creator Eric Kripke’s original choice for the brothers’ car was a 1965 Mustang. He changes his mind after a neighbor said to him that he needs a vehicle that when people stop next to it at lights, they lock their doors.